Review of a book from Highgate Library

Michael O’Callaghan reviews A History of Modern France, Volume 1, 1715 – 1799 by Alfred Cobban

This vivid narrative of 18th century France is written in a powerful , dense and authoritative style that demands concentration from the reader. It is a model of beautiful English, communicating intense meaning with intricate sentences and a large vocabulary.

In the interests of speed, Professor Cobban occasionally introduces characters or concepts without detailed explanation. Maybe this foible, more common in British textbooks than in American ones, explains why an Amazon reviewer found this book unreadable (it isn’t).

The Internet has given this book new life and made it more accessible. Although Cobban can pack 140 years into one scintillating sentence, sometimes non-historians like me might wonder what, for example, a Jansenist is. I know now, partly from supplementing my reading with Internet lookups.

Everyone can enjoy Cobban’s memorable descriptions, like this one:

‘The Duc de Bourbon was ugly, blind in one eye, bandy-legged, and stupid, but as the next prince of the blood he succeeded to Philip of Orleans. The best thing about him was his mistress, Mme de Prie, pretty, intelligent, and ambitious, as was the way of mistresses, daughter of a financier and moving in financial circles, as was also often the way of mistresses in the eighteenth century. ‘

The 1700s was the age of the libertine. The king and other male aristocrats were distracted by “lascivious little beauties”. There existed a job title, I can only call it that, of Offical Mistress to the King. Madame de Pompadour in this role was in effect a government minister, and one of the better ones. The events and people of this period are remarkable and to understand them is to gain a deep education in power and politics.



About s1bc

Chairman of library support group and chief blogger. Active library user since childhood and beyond. Book devourer. Grandparent and pensioner. Fighter for libraries.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s